top of page

What Small Businesses Should Know About Fees, Results, and Red Flags

1 day ago
15 min read

Jordan Baker is the founder of Fair Public Relations, a journalist-led PR agency supporting founders, experts, and growing businesses. A former UK national journalist, he has more than a decade of experience in PR, media relations, and earned media strategy.

Executive Contributor Jordan Baker Brainz Magazine

Hiring a PR agency can be surprisingly difficult to compare. One company might quote a few hundred pounds a month, another several thousand, and another tens of thousands for work that, on the surface, all seems to be called “PR”. After more than a decade working in PR, and before that working as a journalist, I think the mistake is starting with the price. I would start with a much more basic question. What are you actually buying, and is PR even the right thing for your business to be buying yet?


Historic downtown street with colorful storefronts, balconies, and signs for CC Herber Co, Texas Trail, and Allen’s Boots.

PR is not automatic


One of the most common misunderstandings I hear on discovery calls is that hiring a PR agency somehow switches publicity on. A business pays the retainer, the agency sends out a press release, journalists receive it, and articles start appearing. I can understand why somebody who has never worked with the media might imagine it works like that, because a lot of PR is still sold in a way that makes the process sound far more mechanical than it really is.


Sometimes coverage does happen quickly. We have had journalists come back almost immediately because the story was timely, the source was exactly what they needed, or the product happened to land at the right moment. But that is not the normal journey I would tell a client to expect.


The journey is usually positioning, content creation, pitching, learning, adapting, and building credibility with journalists over time. It is working out what somebody can genuinely talk about, which parts of their experience are interesting outside their own business, and which angles sound exciting internally but are unlikely to mean very much to a newsroom. It is testing ideas, changing the emphasis when journalists are not biting, and noticing when one subject consistently gets more interest than another.


For a product or service, there is another layer. Is it genuinely different? Is it available now? Is the price clear? Is the photography good enough for a publication to use? Can samples be sent quickly? Is there a founder story behind it? Are the claims supportable? Is there a reason this particular product matters this month rather than six months from now? Sometimes the difference between a story moving and dying is something as mundane as having the right high-resolution photograph ready when the journalist asks for it.


This is also why I think the traditional idea that PR is mainly about having a “little black book” of journalists is overstated. I wrote about that in my first Brainz article. Relationships matter, but mostly because journalists learn which PR people are useful, accurate, and realistic. If I repeatedly send a journalist stories that fit their beat, answer questions properly, and do not waste their time, they are more likely to open my next email. That is a relationship. It still does not mean they owe me coverage.


The media is made up of people. People change jobs, go on holiday, get pulled onto breaking stories, abandon features, have their budgets changed, lose pages, get a different editor, or simply decide that an idea which looked good on Monday is no longer worth pursuing on Thursday. That uncertainty is not a flaw in PR. It is part of what earned media is.


This is why I am always uncomfortable when somebody asks for guaranteed coverage as though a PR agency can control an editor’s final decision. A reputable PR agency can guarantee the work it will do. It cannot guarantee what an independent journalist will do with it. I think about it in much the same way I would think about a good law firm or a good surgeon. You are paying for professional judgement, preparation, skill, and execution. You are not buying ownership of the outcome.


Know what you are buying


The words “PR agency” cover an enormous range of businesses. That is one reason comparing fees can be so misleading.


One agency may be running corporate communications across several countries. Another may specialise in crisis work. Another may be organising celebrity events, product launches, and influencer activity. Another may be helping founders become more visible in business media. Another may spend most of its time responding to journalist requests on behalf of a small group of experts. Those are not simply expensive and cheap versions of the same service.


A psychologist who wants to become a credible source for journalists does not necessarily need the same team, workload, or campaign structure as a consumer brand launching six products. A £50 million business dealing with regulatory issues, internal communications, and several markets may genuinely need a large integrated agency with specialist teams. A founder who wants somebody experienced to identify useful stories, write the material, and pitch the media may not.


If I were buying PR, I would ask an agency to explain what it actually intends to do for me in very plain language. What does it think the media opportunity is? What stories can it already see? Which journalists or types of publication does it think could care, and why? Is it creating proactive stories, responding to reactive opportunities, or both? Who will interview me? Who writes the copy? Who pitches? Who follows up? Who handles journalist questions? What happens if the original angle does not work? How much of my time will be required? Those questions tell you far more than the monthly number on the proposal.


The Chartered Institute of Public Relations (CIPR) publishes guidance for organisations choosing public relations support, and I think that is a useful mindset. Hiring an agency is a professional buying decision. You should understand the scope, the people, the responsibilities on both sides, and what success can realistically look like.


I would also ask what is not included. Product samples, photography, events, travel, testing, specialist legal advice, or research can all create additional costs depending on the campaign. If those things are going to be important, I would rather know before signing than discover halfway through that the “£1,000-a-month campaign” really requires another several thousand pounds of client-side expenditure.


What small businesses should know about PR agency fees?


I do not believe expensive PR is automatically good PR. I also do not believe inexpensive PR is automatically good value. The useful question is whether the fee matches the work.


If somebody offers a very low-cost service but most of the labour remains with you, that matters. I see services where a client is effectively given access to journalist opportunities and then has to decide which ones are relevant, research the subject, write the answers, and make sure everything is sent on time. That can be absolutely fine for somebody with the time and confidence to do it. But the subscription fee is not the whole cost. Your own time is part of the cost too.


The opposite can happen at the expensive end. A large agency may quote a significant retainer because it is putting a genuinely substantial team around the account. If you need public affairs, crisis support, international coordination, events, senior corporate counsel, and multiple specialist functions, that might be money well spent. If you are a ten-person business that mainly needs good media judgement and consistent outreach, you may be paying for an infrastructure you do not really need.


At Fair PR, we deliberately separate two different services for exactly this reason. Our focused Expert Commentary PR service is currently £397 a month in the UK and is designed for eligible specialists whose knowledge can genuinely help journalists. Our broader Standard PR service is £797 a month in the UK and covers wider company, founder, product, and service publicity with more strategic account involvement. They are not the same job at two price points. The lower-priced service is narrower by design.


Another agency may package its work completely differently, and that is fine. I would not use our prices as an industry benchmark. I would use them as an example of why a buyer needs to compare scope before deciding whether something is “cheap”.


The same applies when somebody tells me another agency charges £3,000, £5,000, or £10,000 a month. That number by itself tells me almost nothing. What are they actually doing? Who is doing it? What expertise are they bringing? How much of the founder’s time are they taking away? Are there additional costs? Is the client buying a team it genuinely needs?


For me, price only becomes meaningful once the job is clear.


A £90,000 lesson


One of the experiences that shaped my view on this happened quite early in my PR career. Around 2016, I met the couple behind Boogie Bounce, a fitness business in Tamworth in the UK. They were lovely people with an energetic product, and, from memory, they had previously been quoted somewhere in the region of £90,000 for a three-month PR campaign.


The proposed campaign was big. It involved a major London launch, a celebrity figurehead, and a lot of surrounding activity. I am not saying that proposal was inherently wrong. There are brands for which spending £90,000 on a high-profile launch is entirely rational. If the budget is there, the commercial opportunity supports it, and the scale of the activity is genuinely needed, a large campaign can make sense.


I just did not think this particular business needed to spend anything close to that amount to create something useful.


We ended up doing our own version of some of the ideas on a dramatically smaller budget. We organised a London event, invited journalists to experience the class, had health and lifestyle writers there, arranged interviews, and brought in a celebrity figurehead. That particular event cost somewhere around £3,000, including the different elements around it, food and drink, and photography.


The celebrity also posted about Boogie Bounce across her social channels. The response was so strong that the traffic surge took their website down. At the event, journalists were interviewing her and trying the class for themselves.


I do not tell that story because I think every £3,000 event can replace a £90,000 campaign. It obviously cannot. Nor do I know what the more expensive proposal might have achieved if the client had gone ahead with it.


What stayed with me was the importance of working backward from the business rather than forwards from the biggest campaign an agency knows how to sell.


What does this client actually need? Where is the opportunity? What can realistically move the business forward? What is proportionate to the size of the company and its budget?


I think small businesses should expect an agency to answer those questions before it starts adding expensive components to a proposal.


Ask who does the work


This is one of the simplest questions a prospective client can ask, and one of the most important. Who is actually going to work on my account?


A founder can have a brilliant sales meeting with an agency owner, managing director, or very senior strategist and come away believing that is the person who will be thinking about the business every week. After signing, the day-to-day work may sit with people they never met.


That is not automatically a criticism. Junior PR professionals can be excellent, and a properly managed team is often more effective than one senior person trying to do absolutely everything. The point is transparency.


I would want to understand who decides strategy, who develops angles, who writes, who pitches, who handles urgent journalist requests, and who is responsible when something is not working. I would also want to know how the senior experience being sold to me actually feeds into the campaign after the sales process.


At Fair, for example, I remain directly involved in strategy and account calls for our broader Standard PR clients while the wider team supports content, pitching, media opportunities, and delivery. Our narrower Expert Commentary PR service is deliberately more team-led. That is an intentional difference in scope. Neither model is automatically better. What matters is that the client knows what they are buying.


I also think case studies matter here. Not simply a page of famous publication logos, but evidence that the agency has worked with people or businesses facing a similar media challenge. If I were a therapist, I would be more interested in seeing that an agency understands how therapists can be useful to journalists than seeing that it once put an unrelated celebrity into a newspaper. If I were launching a consumer product, I would want to see whether the team understands reviews, samples, imagery, long-lead media, and product storytelling.


Connections matter. Experience matters. But relevant experience matters more than a giant collection of logos.


Understand what progress means


Another question I hear is, “How many articles will I get each month?” I completely understand why people ask. A business is committing money and wants to know what it will receive in return. But genuine earned media is not really sold in neat monthly units.


There are several stages between an agency doing work and a customer eventually making money from that work, and I think clients are better served when those stages are separated rather than bundled together as “results”.


If an agency sends 500 emails, that is activity. If a journalist replies and asks for more information, that is journalist interest. If the journalist arranges an interview or asks detailed follow-up questions, that is stronger interest. If an article is published, that is an editorial result. If somebody clicks through from the article, that is an audience response. If that person later becomes a qualified enquiry, that is a commercial outcome. Those things can form part of the same journey, but they are not the same thing.


This is why I do not find raw outreach numbers particularly impressive by themselves. If somebody has sent hundreds of pitches and nobody relevant has responded, I would want to know what is being changed. Equally, if journalists are interviewing the client, requesting information, and actively working on stories, I would not necessarily decide a campaign is failing because an article has not landed before the next invoice date. There needs to be some judgement.


“PR takes time” is true, but I do not think it should be used as a shield against accountability. If months are passing with no coverage, no useful journalist conversations, and no clear evidence that the media proposition is getting stronger, I would expect a good agency to question its own approach. Change the angle, narrow the positioning, improve the evidence, try a different audience, or, if necessary, admit that the opportunity is weaker than originally thought.


Our own services begin with an initial three-month commitment. I see that as a contractual starting point, not an editorial promise. Three months gives enough time to understand a client, develop positioning, create material, begin pitching, and learn something from the response. It does not mean three newspapers now owe the client an article.


Personally, I also think a business should ideally be financially comfortable looking at PR over something closer to six months when it is assessing whether the investment makes sense. That does not mean blindly paying an agency for six months while nothing happens. It means I would not want a client reaching week six and desperately needing the next article to generate enough revenue to pay the next invoice.


Earned media is too unpredictable to carry that sort of short-term financial pressure.


Sometimes I say no


One of the biggest red flags in choosing a PR agency, in my opinion, is an agency that thinks everybody should buy PR. They should not.


I recently spoke to a fitness influencer whom I thought had genuine publicity potential. There were things the media could potentially be interested in, and I could imagine us working well together. But as we talked, it became clear to me that more visibility was not the immediate problem.


She needed better systems around her content creation and more ways to monetise the attention she already had. If we generated more publicity before those things were in place, we could simply create more work for her without creating a clear route for the additional attention to become a stronger business.


So I gave her some recommendations about systemising the content side and thinking through additional products. I introduced her to one of our existing clients, Systems Rami, who specialises in building business systems, and they have already done some great work together. Hopefully, we will work with her in 2027, when I think PR will be able to add value much faster.


I would much rather do that than persuade somebody to start paying us a few months too early. I had a similar conversation with a woman selling a very specialist type of swimming pool, mainly to architects, builders, and property developers. It was an interesting product, but I told her I did not think PR was the best first use of her budget.


The reason was simple. Her market was highly identifiable. She broadly knew who the buyers were, and those buyers could be contacted directly. If the immediate objective was to sell more pools, I thought a good business-to-business (B2B) sales agency, direct outreach, LinkedIn, networking, or even a carefully researched list of relevant architects and developers would probably produce a faster commercial return than trying to build broad public awareness.


PR might have become useful later. It could help with credibility, brand awareness, search visibility, and the wider reputation of the company. But if you sell something very niche to a relatively small group of identifiable buyers, there are situations where simply speaking directly to those buyers is the sensible answer.


I think the same principle applies to local businesses. If a small gym urgently needs twenty more members next month but has a poor website, weak local listings, hardly any reviews, and a broken enquiry process, I would probably fix those things before spending the budget on national PR. A brilliant quote in a newspaper does not compensate for nobody answering the phone.


PR works best when it sits inside a business that is ready to use the attention.


You may not need us


There is another thing PR agencies probably do not say often enough. You may be perfectly capable of doing some of this yourself.


Brainz has previously published useful advice on how small businesses can approach media coverage without a large agency budget, and I agree with that principle. In some sectors, there is a steady appetite for credible experts. Health, personal finance, property, interiors, gardening, fitness, and professional services all produce journalist requests where somebody knowledgeable can potentially contribute.


If you have time, understand your subject, can write clearly, and have somebody in the business who can help monitor opportunities, a journalist-request platform or direct DIY outreach may be enough. An assistant, virtual assistant (VA), or intern can sometimes handle much of the administration while the expert supplies the actual knowledge.


There are freelance consultants, PR coaches, distribution services, journalist-request platforms, and managed services at different price points too. The market is not simply “do everything yourself” at one end and “hire a full agency” at the other.


Fair tends to make the most sense when somebody has genuine media potential but does not have the time, confidence, or specialist PR knowledge to execute consistently. We sit somewhere between doing the work yourself and paying for a much larger traditional agency programme. We bring experience, media judgement, writing, pitching, and connections, while keeping the structure relatively lean.


That does not make us the right answer for everybody. I actually think an agency becomes more credible when it can tell a prospect when another route would suit them better.


What I would ask


If I were a small-business owner choosing a PR agency today, I would spend less time asking who has the most glamorous pitch deck and more time trying to understand how they think.


I would ask what they think my strongest media opportunity is right now. Not a generic description of my industry, but an actual idea. If they have spent time looking at my business, what can they see?


I would ask who will work on the account after I sign, how senior experience remains involved, and what the team will need from me. I would ask for relevant case studies, and I would pay attention to whether the agency explains the limitations in those case studies as well as the successes.


I would ask what the monthly fee covers and what sits outside it. I would want the minimum term, notice period, and cancellation process explained clearly. I would ask what happens if the first ideas do not work and how the agency judges whether a campaign is building momentum.


I would be careful with guarantees. “We have achieved this kind of coverage for similar clients before and think you have a strong opportunity” sounds like professional confidence. “We guarantee you will be in this newspaper next month” makes me want to understand exactly what is being sold.


I would also be cautious of an agency that talks endlessly about relationships without saying much about the story. A connection can help get something looked at, but journalism still has to work for the audience.


I would look for a degree of honesty that can sometimes sound less impressive in the sales meeting. I want somebody who is willing to say an angle is weak, a publication is unrealistic, a claim needs evidence, the timing is wrong, or PR should wait.


For me, that is part of the value of paying for expertise. As I wrote recently for Brainz, media coverage can create a wider public record around a person or business that may matter not only to potential customers and journalists but also as people increasingly use search and artificial intelligence (AI) tools to research who they trust. I think that makes credible earned media more interesting, not less. But it does not change the fundamental buying decision.


You are not buying newspaper articles by the kilo. You are buying professional judgement, time, creativity, writing, pitching, media knowledge, relationships, persistence, and the ability to adapt when the first idea does not work. You are buying somebody to navigate a people business in which the final editorial decision belongs to somebody else.


A good PR agency should be able to explain what it can control, what it cannot control, and why it believes the work is worth doing for your particular business. Sometimes the most useful thing it can tell you is that you are not ready yet.


Follow me on LinkedIn for more info!

Read more from Jordan Baker

Jordan Baker, PR Agency Founder

Jordan Baker is the founder of Fair Public Relations, a founder-led, journalist-led PR agency working with founders, experts, professional services firms and growing businesses across the UK, US and Canada. A former UK national journalist, Jordan has more than a decade of experience in public relations, media relations and earned media. He founded the agency in London in 2015 and remains directly involved in client strategy, positioning and campaign direction. His work focuses on helping credible people and businesses turn their expertise, stories and ideas into meaningful media opportunities.

This article is published in collaboration with Brainz Magazine’s network of global experts, carefully selected to share real, valuable insights.

Article Image

The Invisible Ceiling and the Beliefs Quietly Running Your Business

There is an old story about a baby elephant tied to a small wooden stake. Every day it pulls against the rope, and every day the rope holds. One day, it stops pulling. Years later, that elephant weighs...

Article Image

Pre-Builder or In-Seat Builder? How to Build Your 90-Day Plan for a New Leadership Role

Some leaders have a 90-day plan drafted before the promotion is even announced. Others won't write a word of it until they're in the chair and can see what they've inherited. Every time I describe...

Article Image

Spiritual Intelligence vs. Emotional Intelligence – Why Emotional Capacity Matters

I have spent much of my life paying attention to what sits beneath the surface: the feeling in a room, the shifts in someone’s energy, the things people communicate without saying them out loud. I have had powerful...

Article Image

Closer to Hell on Earth and What an Ordinary Office Afternoon Costs a Neurodivergent Mind

It is mid-afternoon. You forgot to have lunch because you were too busy working on that presentation. You do not eat breakfast, so it has been more than 16 hours since the last time you ate. “Maybe...

Article Image

The Erosion of Values Through Scale, Speed, and Automation

Modern organisations have long celebrated speed: faster delivery, faster decisions, faster innovation, faster customer response, and faster transformation. For decades, technological progress has been closely...

Article Image

I Am, Therefore I Think – Reconsidering Descartes

A woman I will call Anna sits across from me. She is a composite of many people I have worked with over four decades, and her words will be familiar to anyone who has ever struggled. She is accomplished...

The Invisible Ceiling and the Beliefs Quietly Running Your Business

Pre-Builder or In-Seat Builder? How to Build Your 90-Day Plan for a New Leadership Role

Spiritual Intelligence vs. Emotional Intelligence – Why Emotional Capacity Matters

Closer to Hell on Earth and What an Ordinary Office Afternoon Costs a Neurodivergent Mind

The Erosion of Values Through Scale, Speed, and Automation

I Am, Therefore I Think – Reconsidering Descartes

I Stopped Chasing the Number and Started Studying What Created It

You Call It Incompatibility, Your Nervous System Calls It a Trauma Response

Beyond Toxic or Supportive and Understanding the People We Turn To

bottom of page