Pre-Builder or In-Seat Builder? How to Build Your 90-Day Plan for a New Leadership Role
Written by Dr. Jessica Herbert, PCC, Executive Coach
Dr. Jessica Herbert, PCC, has held every seat: investigator, cyber manager, data scientist, academic, nationwide consultant, and executive coach across 36 states, 100+ communities, and four countries. She writes about leadership, people, and technology from the inside, never from theory. Proven. Not Promised.
Some leaders have a 90-day plan drafted before the promotion is even announced. Others won't write a word of it until they're in the chair and can see what they've inherited. Every time I describe these two leaders, someone asks me which one is doing it right. That's the wrong question, and the right one could save your first 90 days.

What does it mean to be ready for a leadership transition?
Being ready is not having every answer on day one. It is having a way to keep learning, deciding, and taking care of yourself while the answers arrive.
Over 27 years and more than 100 agencies, I have coached leaders through promotions, new commands, restructures, and selection into roles they had wanted for a decade. I have watched leaders who looked completely prepared stumble, and leaders who looked unprepared find their footing quickly. What separated them was rarely the plan itself. It was how they related to the plan once reality showed up.
The stakes are real. McKinsey's review of the research on leadership transitions found that two years after an executive transition, between 27 and 46 percent are regarded as failures or disappointments. The same analysis found that most new leaders, 92 percent of those hired from outside and 72 percent of those promoted from within, take well beyond 90 days to reach full productivity.
So the first 90 days are not a deadline for mastery. They are the window in which your habits, your credibility, and your rhythm get set. That changes what a good 90-day plan is for.
2 leaders, 1 transition
Over the last couple of years, two leaders I coached showed me this pattern more clearly than any framework could.
The first was a public safety leader stepping into a bigger seat. They had ideas, plenty of them, but they chose to wait until they were in the role to build the plan. Then the ground moved. People left. The budget changed. Instead of observing and then outlining, they were building in real time, under the stress of challenges no one had flagged, with no earlier thinking to lean on.
The second was an executive who had everything built before day one: the priorities, the milestones, what needed to be true at 30, 60, and 90 days. They held to that plan through the transition. What they had not planned for was that the people around them were not on the same page. Resistance showed up. Their communication style was stretched as they moved the organization through the change curve, and eventually they had to reset everyone's expectations for the timeline, including their own.
Neither leader did it wrong. Each one ran into the edge of their own strength.
The pre-builder and the in-seat builder
The Pre-Builder plans before the transition. Once selected, and sometimes before, they roll out the whiteboard and sketch the 90 days. They know it won't be executed perfectly. The plan is not a prediction. It is what lets them sleep at night, and it sets direction for themselves and for the people who will follow them.
The In-Seat Builder waits. They think about the role, sometimes constantly, but they won't commit to an outline until they are in it and can observe how things really work. To them, a plan written from the outside is a plan built on assumptions.
When I describe these two profiles, I always get the same question: which one is better? As a coach, I don't rank them. Every leader is exactly where they need to be in that moment, and each profile carries a real strength and a predictable blind spot.
The Pre-Builder's strength is direction. Their risk is holding the plan longer than reality supports it.
The In-Seat Builder's strength is observation. Their risk is having no scaffolding when the pressure arrives.
Michael Watkins, whose book The First 90 Days remains one of the most useful guides on this subject, makes the point that a transition begins the moment you learn you are being considered for the role, not on your first day. Both profiles can honor that. For the Pre-Builder, the transition starts with the plan. For the In-Seat Builder, it starts with preparing yourself to build one.
Why the first 30 days test both profiles
A transition is a learning curve. New responsibilities, new expectations, new relationships, and an organization quietly deciding what kind of leader you are, all at once. You will not perform at your highest while you are still processing all of it. That is not a character flaw. It is the cost of learning in public.
What breaks leaders is rarely the learning curve itself. It is the trades they make to keep up with it: the workout skipped for one more hour at the desk, fast food in the car between meetings, family time given away a little at a time. Nobody decides to stop taking care of themselves. It erodes.
Most new leaders are also on their own. The same McKinsey analysis notes that tailored coaching and customized assimilation plans can double a leader's likelihood of success, yet only about a third of organizations use them. If no one is building a plan for how you will stay well through this, that plan is your job too. It is a different job for each profile. Nick Reich makes a related point in his Brainz piece on why great contributors struggle as new managers: nobody tells people the new role is a different job.
Signs your transition plan needs attention
Whichever profile you are, these are the early signals I look for with the leaders I coach:
You can no longer say what needs to be true by day 90.
Your calendar is full, and almost none of it maps to your priorities.
Decisions are waiting on you that someone else could make.
People agree in the meeting, and nothing moves afterward.
The routines that keep you steady, such as exercise, sleep, and time with family, have quietly become negotiable.
5 steps to a 90-day plan that fits how you lead
Both profiles go through the same 90 days. What changes is the action each one takes at each step.
1. Decide what works for you, now and later
If you are a Pre-Builder, roll out the whiteboard. Build your Gantt chart. Name the key pillars you want to see come to life and what needs to be true for each of them. Then hold it until it is time. Even if you know it may all change, you will have scaffolding to work from.
If you are an In-Seat Builder, you are not writing the plan yet, so define what needs to be true for you to build it well once you are in the seat. Protect the priorities that keep you balanced, like workouts and family time. Then start adjusting your routines now to the schedule you are about to take on, so the shift doesn't land on you all at once.
2. Balance what you think should happen with what you observe
You are now in the position, absorbing new information from a new seat.
If you are a Pre-Builder, manage your expectations. Your plan will be challenged. Parts of it may be wrong. All of it will need editing. Treat each contradiction as information, not as failure.
If you are an In-Seat Builder, start building your scaffolding now, and build it without the bias of what is presented to you. It is easy to absorb the logic of "how we've always done it," or to accept explanations that sound reasonable but are passive resistance to change. Understand that logic. Don't adopt it as your plan.
3. Check in with yourself around day 30
Regardless of profile, it is normal for things to go off the rails about 30 days in.
If you are a Pre-Builder, your plan may look like a mess, and you may not know how to reorganize it and give it life again. Go back to your pillars and to what needs to be true. Keep what still holds, revise what reality has changed, and tell people what changed and why. Resetting the timeline out loud builds more trust than defending the original one.
If you are an In-Seat Builder, you are sorting out new information while performing day to day. This is the moment to get your observations onto paper, even roughly. A rough outline at day 30 is far more useful than a perfect one you never write.
For both, stress is high. Check whether you are cutting corners, skipping the gym, or living on fast food to buy another hour of work. That hour costs more than it gives back.
4. Rebuild your time
This is where I use what I call a time audit: an honest comparison of what you are doing against what your week should look like for you to perform well. In the weeds of a transition, it is easy to lose sight of the outcome that matters, which is a successful first 90 days as a new leader.
For Pre-Builders, the audit shows whether your calendar reflects the pillars you built. For In-Seat Builders, it becomes some of your best observation data, because it shows the real rhythm of the organization you just inherited.
5. Delegate, then delegate again
Chances are you are doing things you shouldn't be doing, either because it feels easier to do them yourself or because you don't yet know how to delegate with clarity. Your time audit should show you which time to protect so you can build that clarity: the outcome you want, the decisions that belong to the other person, and when they should come back to you. That is how work keeps moving without you being there from sunup to sundown. Hulya Kurt's Brainz article on the delegation dilemma is a useful companion here.
For Pre-Builders, delegating pieces of the plan does double duty. Ownership is one of the fastest ways to get people on the same page. For In-Seat Builders, delegating early buys back the time you need to observe, think, and build.
Lead the way you are wired, and prepare for the edge of it
You don't have to become a different kind of leader to get through a transition well. You must know where your approach will be tested and decide ahead of time how you will respond. The Pre-Builder needs permission to let the plan change and needs to know where to return to the scaffolding. The In-Seat Builder needs a small amount of structure before the pressure arrives. Both need a week that leaves room to think and realign; neither wants to work 16-hour days to make it work.
As Carla Madeleine Kupe writes in her Brainz article, Transition is the Work that Change Leaves Behind, sometimes you need to let go of things to be ready for what is next. Letting this work go so you can focus on what is next is exactly the challenge you will see in the first 30 days as a Pre-Builder or In-Seat Builder. Delegating quickly and effectively will help you settle into your new role and make space for what is next. If you want to keep up with stories of transitions and techniques to navigate them, subscribe to Leading Through Change. I share what I am seeing in real transitions, the patterns that derail good leaders, and the small practices that keep them steady. You can bring me your questions.
Read more from Dr. Jessica Herbert, PCC
Dr. Jessica Herbert, PCC, Executive Coach
Dr. Jessica Herbert, PCC, has spent 27 years at the intersection of public safety, data analytics, and organizational change, not as a theorist, but as the detective in the networks, the orchestrator behind the analytical team, the scientist building the models, and the consultant and coach leading change across 36 states and 100+ communities in the United States. She is the founder of IDEA Analytics and Asbatra Coaching, companies that bring leadership, people, and technology together to find their path to high performance. Her work is built on a simple conviction: data helps us think and behave differently, but lasting change requires transforming both the system and the people running it.










