The Human Side of Innovation – Katie Smetherman Holmes on AI and the Future of Web Design

Artificial Intelligence is everywhere, from chatbots to design tools, and it’s revolutionizing how we create digital experiences. But where does that leave the human element in design? Can technology really replace the creativity, empathy, and connection that make brands resonate?

We sat down with Katie Smetherman Holmes, founder and CEO of Brand Studio Creative and an international best-selling author, to discuss the role of AI in web design, the importance of human connection, and why heart-driven creativity will never go out of style.

Katie, AI is showing up in almost every industry right now. How do you see it changing web design?

AI is definitely transforming how we work. It can cut down research time, streamline production, and even automate repetitive tasks like saving endless file variations. That’s a huge win because it frees us up to spend more time on the parts that matter the most, strategy, storytelling, and human connection. But here’s the thing, AI should support creativity, not replace it. Web design is still about creating experiences that make people feel something. And no matter how smart AI gets, it can’t replicate empathy or human connection.

Some entrepreneurs worry that using AI might make their websites feel less authentic. How do you balance the two?

That’s such a great question. AI can absolutely help with efficiency, but if you let it do all the work, your brand risks feeling hollow. At Brand Studio Creative, we use AI as a tool, but we always refine, tweak, and humanize it before it ever reaches a client. I think of it this way, AI can hand you the brush and the paint, but the masterpiece still comes from your own perspective, your own heart. People don’t connect with perfect, they connect with real.

Do you think AI could ever replace creative jobs like graphic or web design?

Honestly, no. It might shift our roles, but it won’t replace the need for human creatives. Creativity is about interpretation, two people can look at the same painting and feel completely different emotions because of their unique experiences. AI doesn’t have that kind of depth. It doesn’t involve lived experience, memory, or empathy. It can mimic, but it can’t truly feel. And design is all about emotion and connection. What I do see is our workflow evolving. AI will continue to handle more of the operational or time-consuming tasks, while humans lean even more into creativity, storytelling, and client connection.

So, for you, the heart of your business is still human connection?

Absolutely. My business is built on human connection, empathy, and heart. I love connecting with clients, listening to their stories, and translating that into a brand or website that feels like them. That part will never change for me. Even if AI could technically do what I do, I’d still want to do it because I’m passionate about it. What I do want AI to help with are the things I don’t necessarily enjoy, like file management, research, or production tasks that eat up time. That way, I can give more energy to what matters most, people.

For small businesses dipping their toes into AI, what advice would you give?

Start small and stay intentional. Don’t feel like you have to overhaul your entire workflow with AI tools. Instead, find one or two areas where AI could save you time, like using AI-powered layout generators, accessibility checkers, or content brainstorming tools. But always filter the results through your own voice, values, and strategy. Think of AI as a supportive assistant, not the decision-maker. The human touch should always come first.

Looking ahead, what excites you the most about the relationship between AI and design?

Honestly, the possibilities are exciting! AI can help us move faster and test ideas in ways we couldn’t before. Imagine being able to prototype a design concept instantly, and then spend your real creative energy refining the story and the emotional impact. That’s powerful. I’m excited about how these tools can make design more accessible for entrepreneurs and small businesses, too, it lowers barriers to entry. But the real magic is still in the human layer, using those tools to create experiences that inspire, educate, and transform. That’s where the future lies.

If you had to sum it up, what’s the key takeaway about AI and web design?

AI is a tool, not the designer. It can speed things up, simplify processes, and even spark inspiration, but it can’t replace the human heart. People don’t hire you or fall in love with your brand because you’re efficient. They connect with you because you make them feel seen, heard, and understood. So yes, leverage AI where it makes sense, but never let it take away the most important part of design, the human connection.

In a digital world that’s becoming increasingly automated, Katie reminds us that the future of web design isn’t about replacing humans with AI, it’s about using AI to give humans more space to create, connect, and inspire. After all, algorithms can design a website, but only humans can make it unforgettable.

To learn more about Katie’s approach to branding and design, or to explore how Brand Studio Creative can help elevate your business, visit her website here.

Follow me on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn for more info!

Read more from Katie Smetherman Holmes