top of page

5 Reasons Why Your New Year's Resolutions Fail

  • Writer: Brainz Magazine
    Brainz Magazine
  • Dec 30, 2024
  • 5 min read

Updated: Jan 2, 2025

Dr. Attaway has worked in Holistic Women's Health for nearly 20 years. Her clinical experiences are now translated into coaching groups, workshops, and written media. She promotes simple strategies for getting and staying healthy.

Executive Contributor Dr. Erin Attaway

We all love to start the year by setting big goals for ourselves. New Year, New You. Right? Although we love setting the goal, we don't love planning the work to achieve it. Most of the time, the goal is arbitrary, like “in 2025, I will finally lose this 10 pounds I’ve been carrying.”


Young woman celebrating new year

But that’s the extent of the planning. Or, we make a crazy plan like:


  • Cutting calories to 1200

  • Working out every day for an hour

  • Hiring a personal trainer for three days a week

  • Giving up sugar entirely

  • Joining a tennis team

  • Using a fitness tracker every day

 

And then all of that feels crazy, so you stop doing it in a few weeks. Changes are most effective when they are small, meaningful, measurable, and compounding. This means that you must decide what feels most important, most likely, and most accessible. And start with that.

 

5 reasons that you don’t stick to your resolutions

 

1. Your goals are arbitrary

You choose something that sounds good or desirable but doesn't have precision or value. Yes, 10 pounds sounds good, like the right amount, but that’s a random estimation. What if you actually feel great after losing only seven pounds? Are you a failure if you don’t lose all ten? Instead, try creating a goal that has more value and meaning.

 

“I’m going to lose enough weight to fit comfortably in my favorite jeans, so I don’t have to buy new ones.”

 

Nothing bad will happen if you don’t lose 10 pounds, but you’ll have to spend more money and time investing in more clothes. But choosing a goal that has meaning and serves the purpose of advancing you and preventing you from harm will have a much more lasting impact.

 

The goal to get back into your jeans comfortably means you hit the goal of weight loss, but you also prevent having to waste time and energy on clothing you don’t want. You get the good thing but also avoid the bad thing, and that’s a better incentive to keep pursuing it.


2. Your goals are lofty

We are told to “Dream big,” and that’s wonderful and valuable, but big dreams without plans or action are just dreams. If you start a new business and you dream of earning $250,000 in your first year, that’s great. But is it unlikely? What are the plans for your revenue? Do you think you’ll earn as much in the first month as you will at the end of the year? Probably not.

 

It’s better to set smaller and more manageable goals, like “I plan to earn $25,00 in the first quarter by taking these steps.”

 

Then, set quarterly goals that grow by a reasonable amount. Yes, you do want to imagine the end, but in the beginning, you need to stay in a place that helps you gain confidence and build momentum. If your goals are so far from being plausible, then you can quickly become hopeless and quit. Smaller wins set you up for what’s possible by gaining a little momentum with passing time. Keep moving your goal post, but focus on “Couch to 5K” instead of “Couch to marathon.”


3. You choose too many resolutions

You want to start jogging, meditating, making more time for friends, taking a painting class, building a side hustle, and having a monthly potluck at your house.

 

But that’s not likely to happen. Too many ideas make for chaos, so you have to narrow it down to what feels most important and most likely to stick.

 

So, choose the three things that are most compelling and plan them out each week. If you plan for one thing each day, then by the end of each week, you have accomplished something every day and feel successful.

 

4. You don’t put things on your calendar,r so they don’t get done

For resolutions to stick to, they need to have realistic space on the calendar. In such a busy world, it’s easy to think about doing things but hard to find the time.

 

Planning for days and times makes hitting the target plausible. Don’t think that you are going to go from zero to sixty minutes of walking every day of the week. That’s unlikely to stick.

 

Plan for something more reasonable, like 20-minute walks three days a week. Then, you can easily add more time when it fits or an extra day once you’ve adapted to your new routine.


For example:

 

Plan to practice meditation for 20 minutes on Monday, Wednesday and Friday. Plan to jog for 20 minutes before you get ready for work on Tuesday, Thursday, and Saturday mornings. Take Sunday off and spend that time working on your calendar and next week’s plan.


Planning for changes works best when your list is simple and mapped out. Don’t try to hit 6 targets every day, and it won’t work. Try for one or two, and be realistic. In a month, when you are successful at those, you will add the next step. You are building on small wins and making habits that last.

 

5. You are adding more “work” to your already hectic life

Most of the time, we choose resolutions that are designed to make us better, more successful, more prolific, and more athletic, but we are already strapped for time and energy, so is adding more always the best answer?

 

Most people suffer from excess productivity and lack of free time. That’s a recipe for burnout.

 

Instead of just adding more to your daily to-do list, try taking things away.

 

This year, strip your calendar of things that wear you down. Give up a board seat, add an extra parent to your carpool group, and leave work at 2 on Fridays. Find places where you can cut things off the list and make more time for yourself.

 

Without any time for spontaneity and creativity, we burn ourselves out and give up on our goals. When you shift your priorities you can make time; time for yourself!

 

Try making 2025 the year you consistently made small changes, and let each month of successes carry you to the next step. By the end of the year, you will look back at your achievements and feel wildly successful.

 

Choose small, steady, and manageable instead of going big and giving up by February.


Follow me on Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn, and visit my website for more info!

Read more from Dr. Erin Attaway

Dr. Erin Attaway, Doctor of Acupuncture and Chinese Medicine

Dr. Erin Attaway is a leader in Women’s Health and fertility medicine, A busy mother, business owner, and entrepreneur, she promotes reliable and accessible resources for women to integrate into their lives. She believes good health is simple if you’re willing to do the work. Her mission is to empower women everywhere to care for themselves how they deserve.

 
 

This article is published in collaboration with Brainz Magazine’s network of global experts, carefully selected to share real, valuable insights.

Article Image

Why It’s Time to Ditch New Year’s Resolutions in Midlife

It is 3 am. You are awake again, unsettled and restless for no reason that you can name. In the early morning darkness you reach for comfort and familiarity, but none comes.

Article Image

Happy New Year 2026 – A Letter to My Family, Humanity

Happy New Year, dear family! Yes, family. All of us. As a new year dawns on our small blue planet, my deepest wish for 2026 is simple. That humanity finally remembers that we are one big, wonderful family.

Article Image

We Don’t Need New Goals, We Need New Leaders

Sustainability doesn’t have a problem with ideas. It has a leadership crisis. Everywhere you look, conferences, reports, taskforces, and “thought leadership” panels, the organisations setting the...

Article Image

Why Focusing on Your Emotions Can Make Your New Year’s Resolutions Stick

We all know how it goes. On December 31st we are pumped, excited to start fresh in the new year. New goals, bold resolutions, or in some cases, a sense of defeat because we failed to achieve all the...

Article Image

How to Plan 2026 When You Can't Even Focus on Today

Have you ever sat down to map out your year ahead, only to find your mind spinning with anxiety instead of clarity? Maybe you're staring at a blank journal while your brain replays the same worries on loop.

Article Image

Why Christmas Triggers So Many Emotions, and How to Navigate the Season with More Ease

Christmas is supposed to be “the most wonderful time of the year,” yet many people feel overwhelmed inside, anxious, or alone as the holidays approach. If you find yourself dreading family...

Why Wellness Doesn’t Work When It’s Treated Like A Performance Metric

The Six-Letter Word That Saves Relationships – Repair

The Art of Not Rushing AI Adoption

Coming Home to Our Roots – The Blueprint That Shapes Us

3 Ways to Have Healthier, More Fulfilling Relationships

Why Schizophrenia Needs a New Definition Rooted in Biology

The Festive Miracle You Actually Need

When the Tree Goes Up but the Heart Feels Quiet – Finding Meaning in a Season of Contrasts

The Clarity Effect – Why Most People Never Transform and How to Break the Cycle

bottom of page