top of page

Why Collaboration Can Fail Before Anyone Speaks

22 hours ago
4 min read

Updated: 4 hours ago

As founder of Unlock Dynamic, Paul Grainger is a trusted strategic partner to Chief Executive Officers (CEOs), Chief Operating Officers (COOs), and senior leadership teams navigating pressure, change, and complexity. With over 25 years of experience across startups and multinationals, he helps ambitious organisations thrive by addressing the behavioural realities most leadership programs overlook.

Executive Contributor Paul Grainger Brainz Magazine

In fast-moving organisations, leaders are expected to keep things moving, make sensible decisions and avoid wasting colleagues' time. These are usually signs of good judgement. Yet in a recent conversation with a leadership team, I noticed how a well-intentioned decision had quietly worked against collaboration. What happens when trying to do the right thing creates a problem nobody initially recognises?


Business team meeting in a glass-walled office at sunset, with a man speaking, laptops and water glasses on the table.

The moment


During that discussion, one leader asked why several colleagues hadn't been invited to an important planning meeting. The organisers explained that the meeting had been arranged at short notice, and they felt inviting others so late might appear unprofessional.


Rather than inconvenience their colleagues, they decided not to invite them. But those colleagues saw it differently. All said they would much rather have received the invitation, even at short notice, and decided for themselves whether they could attend.


What's really happening?


At first glance, this looked like a simple communication oversight. But the invitation hadn't been forgotten. The organisers had made a conscious decision not to send it.


We often assume collaboration breaks down because people protect their territory, resist cooperation or fail to communicate. Yet here, the obstacle was something less obvious: an assumption about what others would prefer, treated as though it were fact.


The problem wasn't what people said to one another. It was what they'd already decided on one another's behalf.


The cost of what never happened


The planning meeting had apparently gone well. That's precisely what made the potential cost so difficult to see. When relevant perspectives are missing, problems may surface later than necessary, decisions may need revisiting, and teams can spend valuable time reworking plans.


But perhaps the greater cost lies in the opportunities that never emerge: a better solution, a simpler approach or an important connection nobody thought to make.


The value of a better decision that was never made is almost impossible to measure.


Rethinking collaboration


We tend to think of collaboration as something people do: sharing ideas, listening carefully and working constructively across teams. But there's a blind spot in this approach. An organisation can have highly capable, willing collaborators and still fail to benefit from their expertise, simply because the opportunities to contribute aren't always there.


Perhaps improving collaboration isn't just about developing people's ability to work together. It's also about ensuring their knowledge and perspectives have the opportunity to influence decisions when they matter most.


What great leadership teams do differently


Effective leadership teams recognise that the people responsible for making a decision aren't necessarily the only people who can improve it. They look beyond familiar colleagues and established reporting lines to consider who might identify an overlooked risk, challenge an assumption, or recognise a better opportunity.


Sometimes that means involving someone unexpected, even briefly, before a direction becomes difficult to change. This isn't about involving everyone or creating more meetings. It's about recognising the difference between who should make the decision and whose thinking could make it better.


The evidence


Research published in the Journal of Business Research in 2022 suggests that more coordination between teams doesn't necessarily lead to better performance. What matters is how effectively they use each other's knowledge.


A separate 2022 study involving 457 consultants across 22 business units found that sharing knowledge across departments worked better when people knew who had the relevant expertise and actively brought them together.


The distinction is important: connecting people isn't the same as connecting what they know.


A culture of collaboration


Every time leaders decide who to involve, they're doing more than shaping one decision. They're also reinforcing how people seek and share expertise across the organisation.


When leaders repeatedly rely on familiar colleagues and established relationships, those choices can gradually become the norm. People become accustomed to working within their own circles, even when valuable knowledge exists elsewhere. But when seeking different perspectives becomes habitual, people begin making those connections themselves, without waiting for senior leaders to bring them together.


Over time, one of the most valuable capabilities an organisation can develop is knowing when to reach beyond familiar boundaries to find the thinking it needs.


The one question


The next time your leadership team is planning an important meeting, project or decision, ask, "Whose perspective are we assuming we don't need?"


It's a deceptively simple question. We may discover that someone has been left out because we assumed they were too busy, uninterested or unlikely to contribute. But the real value goes beyond one invitation. It encourages teams to question the assumptions behind who gets heard and whose thinking gets overlooked.


Sometimes collaboration fails not because people are unwilling to contribute, but because nobody thought to ask them.


Follow me on LinkedIn and visit my website for more info!

Read more from Paul Grainger

Paul Grainger, Founder of Unlock Dynamic

Paul Grainger focuses on helping capable leaders and teams sustain strong performance over time, beyond conventional approaches that frequently fail to hold up under daily pressure. Drawing on decades of experience, he blends human insight and modern science to offer a practical alternative to conventional leadership thinking. A consistent theme in his work is identifying the invisible performance drains that quietly cost organizations time, energy, and focus.

This article is published in collaboration with Brainz Magazine’s network of global experts, carefully selected to share real, valuable insights.

Article Image

How To Choose Healthy Relationships

Dan Mangena is a best-selling author, entrepreneur, philanthropist and public speaker. Recently named in the Wall St Journal as a Dan Mangena.

Start Now
Article Image

How To Choose Healthy Relationships

Dan Mangena is a best-selling author, entrepreneur, philanthropist and public speaker. Recently named in the Wall St Journal as a Dan Mangena.

Start Now
Article Image

How To Choose Healthy Relationships

Dan Mangena is a best-selling author, entrepreneur, philanthropist and public speaker. Recently named in the Wall St Journal as a Dan Mangena.

Read article now

5 Ways To Leverage User-Generated Content For Business Growth

Dan Mangena is a best-selling author, entrepreneur, philanthropist and public speaker. Recently named in the Wall St Journal as a Dan Mangena.

Start Now

Are We Living Too Short And Dying Too Long?

Dan Mangena is a best-selling author, entrepreneur, philanthropist and public speaker. Recently named in the Wall St Journal as a Dan Mangena.

Start Now

40 Lessons For Startup Success Before 40

Dan Mangena is a best-selling author, entrepreneur, philanthropist and public speaker. Recently named in the Wall St Journal as a Dan Mangena.

Start Now

Heading 3

Start Now

Heading 3

Start Now

Heading 3

Start Now

Heading 3

Start Now

Heading 3

Start Now

Heading 3

Start Now
bottom of page