top of page

The Goodwill Bank and Why Discretionary Effort is the Quiet Cost Nobody is Counting

6 hours ago
6 min read

Reg Goslin is a career coach, founder of Improving Performance personal coaching, and host of The Career Café podcast. After a long career as a sales leader at British Telecommunications (BT), he found his true calling in developing people. Since 2018, he has helped people advance in their careers or change careers in midlife. His message is simple. “It’s your career story. You write the next page.”

Executive Contributor Reg Goslin Brainz Magazine

A few years ago, the phrase on everyone’s lips was “quiet quitting”. It came out of the United States and described people who had decided to do what they were paid for and nothing more. Contracted hours, contracted tasks, and not a minute beyond. No going the extra mile, because the extra mile didn’t seem to lead anywhere.


Bright industrial café with green chairs and empty tables; one person reads a newspaper near a red wall labeled Ethic Cinema.

Here in the United Kingdom (UK), the label may have faded from the headlines, but the mindset hasn’t gone anywhere. If anything, it has quietly settled in. Newer phrases have come along too, such as “job hugging”, which describes people holding on tightly to the job they’ve got because the market feels uncertain. They’re staying put. But staying isn’t the same as giving.


Gallup’s latest State of the Global Workplace report puts engagement among UK employees at around 10%. What strikes me most isn’t that figure on its own. It’s the shape behind it. The great majority of UK workers aren’t angry or actively working against their employer. They’re simply “not engaged”. They come in, they do the job, and they go home.


That isn’t a crisis you can see from the boardroom. It’s a quiet one. I’d suggest it has a name we were using in the UK long before any of these new labels arrived.


Discretionary effort


Discretionary effort is the level of effort a person chooses to give beyond the minimum requirements of their role. The important word there is chooses. You can’t write it into a contract. You can’t demand it in a performance review. It’s given freely, or it isn’t given at all.


During my years leading a sales team at British Telecommunications (BT), I saw it every day, and I came to understand just how much the business quietly depended on it. It was rarely dramatic. It was someone staying an extra half hour to get a proposal out to a client before the deadline. It was someone coming in early to clear up a small problem before it became a big one. It was a phone call returned at ten past five rather than left until the morning.


None of those things would appear in a job description. All of them mattered. Those small acts are what customers and suppliers notice. They build goodwill, and goodwill is what keeps relationships and businesses healthy. The more discretionary effort people give, the better the output and the better the culture. Take it away, and an organisation slowly starts to flounder, often without quite knowing why.


The emotional bank account


Stephen Covey talked about the “emotional bank account”, the idea that every relationship has a balance. Kindness, honesty and keeping your word are deposits. Broken promises and indifference are withdrawals.


I think the relationship between a person and their organisation works in exactly the same way. When the account is in credit, people give their discretionary effort without even thinking about it. It feels natural. They want the business to do well because they feel part of it.


When the account slips into the red, something shifts


I remember calling into a coffee shop one morning on my way to the office and seeing a couple of colleagues sitting there with their newspapers. I asked if they were coming in. “No, not yet,” one of them said. “I’m not working for free.”


I didn’t judge them for it then, and I don’t now. That wasn’t laziness. That was an overdrawn account. Something had been withdrawn long before that morning, and nobody had noticed, or nobody had thought it worth putting right.


Why this lands differently in midlife


Many of us in our forties, fifties and sixties were brought up on the idea that going above and beyond was simply how you got on. You put the hours in, you showed, and eventually it was recognised.


So when that effort stops being noticed, it can sting in a particular way. Perhaps there’s a restructure and your experience suddenly seems to count for less. Perhaps your new manager is twenty years younger and doesn’t know what you used to carry. Perhaps you’ve watched the extra mile turn into the expected mile, with nothing coming back the other way.


In my coaching, I hear this a lot. People rarely say, “I’ve stopped trying.” What they say is, “I just don’t feel like it’s seen anymore.” That’s the sound of an account running low. It matters because experienced people are very often the ones holding things together quietly in the background. When they pull back, the gap shows up in places nobody thought to measure.


A generational gap, in the nicest way


There’s a generational side to this, and I want to be fair about it. Those of us born in the postwar years and the early 1960s grew up with a deal that broadly held. Put the effort in, and it came back to you in security, promotion, and perhaps a house and a decent pension.


Many millennials and members of Generation Z have grown up with a different deal. Higher housing costs, student debt, less secure contracts, and a pandemic that made a great many people stop and ask what work is actually for. So when they hear “go the extra mile”, the reasonable reply is, “What comes back?”


They struggle with the idea of more for nothing, and in the nicest way, I’m not sure they’re wrong. It isn’t that they won’t give discretionary effort. It’s that they want to see the account working both ways before they make a deposit. For employers, that’s no bad thing. It makes the deal visible, and it asks us to keep our side of it.


For employers: Putting credit back in


If you lead people, this is worth taking seriously. Times are uncertain, budgets are tight, and both businesses and individuals are having to make difficult choices. In that climate, discretionary effort isn’t a nice extra. It’s often the difference between a team that copes and one that doesn’t. The good news is that the deposits are rarely expensive.


  • Notice it. The single biggest withdrawal is taking discretionary effort for granted. If someone stayed late to rescue a proposal, say so, specifically and soon.


  • Recognise it properly. Not a generic “thanks, team” at the end of the month, but a sincere acknowledgement of what that person did and the difference it made.


  • Talk about growth. People give more when they can see a future. A genuine conversation about where someone wants to go, at any age, is a deposit in itself.


  • Ask, don’t assume. If you sense someone has gone quiet, ask them how things are. Then listen.


None of this is complicated. But it does have to be deliberate.


For individuals: Checking your own balance


If you’re reading this as someone who has started holding back, I’d gently invite you to sit with a few questions rather than rush to an answer. Where does your account with your organisation stand right now? When did it last feel in credit, and what was different then? What would need to change for you to want to give a little more, and is that within your gift or theirs?


Sometimes a single honest conversation with a manager can start to put things right. Sometimes the account has been overdrawn for so long that the healthier choice is to take your effort, your experience and your goodwill somewhere they will be valued.


Neither answer is wrong. What matters is that it’s a choice you make consciously rather than one that slowly makes itself. It’s your story. You write the next page.


Follow me on Facebook, Instagram, and visit my website for more info!

Read more from Reg Goslin

Reg Goslin, Career Coach

Reg Goslin is a career coach, personal development advocate, and founder of Improving Performance Personal Coaching, dedicated to helping people recognise their potential. Reg’s career journey started at British Telecommunications (BT), where he worked his way through the organisation to a leadership role in middle management. His progression was shaped not only by hard work, determination, and experience but also by the influence of two individuals who made a lasting difference to his development. When Reg changed careers, he trained and qualified as a coach. He then founded Improving Performance Personal Coaching and later launched The Career Café podcast. Reg’s ethos is that having the right person believe in you can change the direction of your career.

This article is published in collaboration with Brainz Magazine’s network of global experts, carefully selected to share real, valuable insights.

Article Image

The Invisible Ceiling and the Beliefs Quietly Running Your Business

There is an old story about a baby elephant tied to a small wooden stake. Every day it pulls against the rope, and every day the rope holds. One day, it stops pulling. Years later, that elephant weighs...

Article Image

Pre-Builder or In-Seat Builder? How to Build Your 90-Day Plan for a New Leadership Role

Some leaders have a 90-day plan drafted before the promotion is even announced. Others won't write a word of it until they're in the chair and can see what they've inherited. Every time I describe...

Article Image

Spiritual Intelligence vs. Emotional Intelligence – Why Emotional Capacity Matters

I have spent much of my life paying attention to what sits beneath the surface: the feeling in a room, the shifts in someone’s energy, the things people communicate without saying them out loud. I have had powerful...

Article Image

Closer to Hell on Earth and What an Ordinary Office Afternoon Costs a Neurodivergent Mind

It is mid-afternoon. You forgot to have lunch because you were too busy working on that presentation. You do not eat breakfast, so it has been more than 16 hours since the last time you ate. “Maybe...

Article Image

The Erosion of Values Through Scale, Speed, and Automation

Modern organisations have long celebrated speed: faster delivery, faster decisions, faster innovation, faster customer response, and faster transformation. For decades, technological progress has been closely...

Article Image

I Am, Therefore I Think – Reconsidering Descartes

A woman I will call Anna sits across from me. She is a composite of many people I have worked with over four decades, and her words will be familiar to anyone who has ever struggled. She is accomplished...

The Invisible Ceiling and the Beliefs Quietly Running Your Business

Pre-Builder or In-Seat Builder? How to Build Your 90-Day Plan for a New Leadership Role

Spiritual Intelligence vs. Emotional Intelligence – Why Emotional Capacity Matters

Closer to Hell on Earth and What an Ordinary Office Afternoon Costs a Neurodivergent Mind

The Erosion of Values Through Scale, Speed, and Automation

I Am, Therefore I Think – Reconsidering Descartes

I Stopped Chasing the Number and Started Studying What Created It

You Call It Incompatibility, Your Nervous System Calls It a Trauma Response

Beyond Toxic or Supportive and Understanding the People We Turn To

bottom of page